Thirsty Pagan

Thirsty Pagan pizzas are made to order using Wisconsin cheese, the finest meats and fresh veggies. Try a Pizza Diane made with pesto, grilled chicken, spinach, tomatoes & special blend of cheeses, it'll rock your taste buds. You can wash it down with one of their craft microbrews.

Runner up: Vintage Italian Pizza (VIP) John Dandrea has owned VIP since the stone age. With three locations and pizza selections ranging from Pepperoni to Chicken Reuben. There’s something everyone can enjoy. Great value. Cooked or uncooked, you can’t go wrong. Banquet facilities available for social or business gatherings.

3rd Place: Sammy’s was sooooo close they could almost taste it.